Charges dropped against accused J train stabber who claimed self-defense

June 29, 2023, 11:23 a.m.

A Brooklyn grand jury declined to indict Jordan Williams for manslaughter and weapons charges for the fatal stabbing of DeVictor Ouedraogo, 36, aboard a J train this month.

A J train approaches the Marcy Av. station in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.

A Queens man who claimed he stabbed a J train passenger in self-defense will not face charges.

A Brooklyn grand jury declined to indict Jordan Williams for manslaughter and weapons charges for the fatal stabbing of DeVictor Ouedraogo, 36, aboard the subway on June 13, the district attorney’s office confirmed.

Brooklyn DA Eric Gonzalez’s office said it conducted "an impartial and thorough investigation" and presented that evidence to the grand jury which dismissed the charges.

A man sits on red steps.

Eyewitness accounts and videos from other passengers showed Ouedraogo acting erratically on the moving train, harassing straphangers, including Williams’ girlfriend. Police said Williams approached Ouedraogo and pushed him away. Ouedraogo fought back before Williams stabbed him, authorities said.

The DA's office said state law allows for a person to use deadly physical force when they believe it's needed "to defend themselves or others from imminent use of deadly or unlawful force.".

Williams was arrested in a subway station and Ouedraogo was rushed to New York Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Hospital, where he died.

The case drew comparisons to the killing of Jordan Neely in May by fellow subway rider Daniel Penny, who also claims self-defense. On Wednesday, Penny pleaded not guilty to manslaughter.

Williams told NBC he was scared as the situation unfolded on the train. “I’m happy that I can get on with my life the way I’d like to,” he said.

An online fundraiser for Williams’ legal fees reached more than $122,000. Williams told NBC that the money will now go toward his college fund.

A man wearing an orange shirt smiles while sitting at a table.

Ouedraogo’s family also created a fundraising page to help with his funeral expenses.

“DeVictor was a cherished member of our family, known for his kind heart, generosity, and unwavering commitment to helping others,” wrote his sister, Marina Ouedraogo. “He touched the lives of many with his selflessness and always had a smile on his face. It is our deepest desire to give him a farewell that reflects the love and admiration we have for him.”

As of Thursday morning, the fundraiser had received $6,500.

A toxicology report will determine whether Ouedraogo was under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time of the incident. A relative had described him as “quiet,” and said he was shocked to hear that Ouedraogo was the victim in a deadly altercation.

Despite several violent incidents over the last few weeks, MTA officials said that crime on the subways has continued to trend downward this year compared to last.

Suspect in Brooklyn J train stabbing released without bail Suspect’s lawyers in Brooklyn J train stabbing compare case to Jordan Neely’s death